Sheila, before her makeover

11 of 12
Tim has seen almost everything during his time on Project Runway, but he's probably never met a woman like Sheila, a 38-year-old who calls herself "scrunchie girl."

Sheila is a jeans and T-shirt kind of girl who curls her bangs under like a jelly roll. Oprah says she used to wear her bangs like that…in high school!