Egg salad

Photo: HandmadePictures/iStock/Thinkstock

Egg, Tuna or Chicken Salads
We were surprised to learn that homemade egg, tuna or chicken salad can last up to seven days in the refrigerator. Just remember that your fridge should be set to 40 degrees or colder, says Jen Tong, global managing director of integrity and process excellence for a division of the public health and safety organization NSF.

One more thing: Take extra precaution by beginning with ingredients that have been chilled (at 40 degrees or below) ahead of time, including even a brand new jar of mayo and a can of tuna. Tong says that's because mixing ingredients together can affect bacterial growth.

Photo: Kesu01/iStock/Thinkstock

Cooked Meats
Poached chicken, grilled steak and roast pork tenderloin all keep well for three to four days in the fridge, says Tong. She recommends putting the items in the refrigerator within two hours, since the less time the food spends at room temperature, the better (and safer).

One more thing: While storing in the freezer is another option, cooked meats tend to lose some of their flavor and texture in supercold temps.
Pepperoni pizza

Photo: barol16/iStock/Thinkstock

Just as with cooked meats, pizza is usually good for three or four days in the refrigerator. (Wrap it tightly to keep it tasting fresh.)

One more thing: If the pizza sat out for a few hours before being refrigerated, Tong says you're safest reheating it before eating. The skillet method is the most effective way we've seen to revive a soggy bottom, giving you a moist crust and making the cheese melt.
Vegetable and noodle soup

Photo: olgna/iStock/Thinkstock

Soups and Chilies
Whether you've made a pot of minestrone, chicken noodle or chili, when it comes to soups and chilies, there are almost always leftovers (and often, the meals taste even better after a day). You can keep enjoying them for three to four days once refrigerated, says Tong. The important thing is to get the temperature down quickly to keep the food in a safe temperature zone (below 40 degrees, or above 140).

One more thing: To speed the cool-down process, try separating large quantities into smaller containers. They can go directly into the fridge at that point; just leave the leftovers partially uncovered while they cool, then cover them completely once they reach fridge temperature.
Chocolate pudding

Photo: Liv Friis-Larsen/iStock/Thinkstock

Everything—and We Mean Everything—Else
While three to four days is a good rule of thumb for most leftovers, there are exceptions (for instance, leftover raw shellfish, such as ceviche or sushi, has a lifespan of just one to two days). For an easy way to determine whether to toss something, there are a number of free apps that can help; one is Is My Food Safe? (a collaboration between the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics and ConAgra Foods), where you can scroll through by category, say, desserts, and go from cakes to puddings. Another is USDA's new FoodKeeper app; among other features, it lets you enter the date you made something and then receive notifications when the food is nearing the end of its recommended storage time.