Sloan and Roger toast to their extraordinary evening.

10 of 16
Just when guests thought the evening was over, Colin's second act was uncovered. Using the stage to his full advantage, Colin lifted the background of the opera set and revealed a Havana-inspired nightclub! "We just looked around and we said, we better take a breath now and enjoy every minute of it because it was the ultimate fantasy for all of us," Sloan says.

"We would probably never experience another night like this as long as we live," Roger says.