2 of 8
CoverGirl Queen Collection Vivid Impact Eyeliner
"These super-pigmented pencils beat out the liners from my favorite high-end brand," says Emily Kate Warren. "They glide easily over the upper lash line and lower inner rim of the eye, and there's a smudger tip on the other end to smooth out any bumps." Best of all, though, are the colors: They all have gorgeous bronze undertones that make every eye color shine.

$7.50, drugstore.com