Photo: Courtesy of the Rockettes

5 of 6
Melissa Hillmer
Favorite Prop: Nars Blush in Deep Throat ($29; "It's halfway between peach and pink, with just a touch of shimmer—subtle, but so flattering. I wear it every day, onstage and off."

Trick of the Trade: "To make your eyes look larger, extend the ends of your brows a bit with a pencil and blend a neutral, illuminating eyeshadow about half an inch past the outer edge of your lids."