Lynn Temepstra in O, the Oprah Magazine

The Goal: Revitalize Color
Lynn Tempesta, 41
Lynn's haircolor history began with salon highlights in her 20s. "But they'd fade so quickly—and cost so much—that I eventually decided just to do them myself," she says. Her method of choice was a hook and cap (you use a hook to poke a hole in a cap and pull through strands of hair to highlight). "My poor husband would have to do the back for me," she says. "Sometimes the results would be great, sometimes they'd look terrible." (This is why Sharon calls the technique "the poke-and-hope.") Then, a couple of years ago, Lynn, a business promoter, decided to take a break and go back to her natural light brown color.

The Lesson Plan

"Lynn's fair skin and light eyes make her an ideal candidate for vibrant red hair," haircoloris Sharon Dorram says. But finding a gorgeous—not brassy, or Bozo—red in a box can be a challenge. To get the right color, don't be afraid to combine two shades. Sharon found the more subdued auburn options too dull but the brighter red colors too fluorescent—so she had Lynn mix L'Oréal Superior Preference in Lightest Auburn ($10, drugstores) and L'Oréal Superior Preference in Intense Red Copper ($10, drugstores). She also chose a highlighting kit, Clairol Nice 'n Easy HairPainting Kit for Light Blonde to Medium Brown Hair ($11, drugstores), so that Lynn could create a few brighter strands around her face. (Caveat emptor: "Highlighting your own hair is no easy feat," says Sharon. "Keep the highlights subtle—no more than six to eight total, and only around the face.") Sharon also notes that while most highlighting kits say they're created for a specific haircolor range, they generally all contain the same combination of active ingredients, and will simply lighten whatever color you start with by two or three shades.

See Lynn's results
Lynn Temepstra in O, the Oprah Magazine

The Reaction
"The color is gorgeous, and just feels right. Everyone's telling me I should always have been a redhead. The change has been so uplifting, I'm definitely going to keep it up at home. I'll probably skip the highlights next time, though, because that process is pretty complicated—and I wouldn't want to ruin the rich red color. If I feel like I really need lighter pieces around my face, I'll get them at the salon."

Gloria Boyce-Charles in O, The Oprah Magazine

The Goal: Cover Gray
Gloria Boyce-Charles, 54
Gloria is a home-haircolor virgin. "I dyed my hair a handful of times in my late 30s—but always in a salon," she says. "My hair is relaxed, so I was afraid it would break off if I tried to dye it myself." And for the past 15 years, Gloria, who runs a nonprofit learning center, has been committed to going gray. "Part of me felt sad as people started offering me seats on trains and calling me ma'am, though," she says. "So when I had the opportunity to color my hair for this story, I took it as a sign."

The Lesson Plan

Gloria is correct: "Relaxed hair is definitely more susceptible to damage," says Sharon. "You can dye it at home, but to be safe, use a demipermanent formula, which contains no ammonia and much less peroxide." For Gloria, Sharon chose Clairol Natural Instincts in Nutmeg Dark Brown ($10, drugstores). "I wanted to lighten Gloria's hair a shade or two to bring out the warm tones in her complexion—going darker would look unnaturally monotone and be too severe against her skin," she says. And Gloria doesn't need highlights to enhance her color: The dye won't stain her grays quite as much as the rest of her hair, creating natural dimension.

See Gloria's results
Gloria Boyce-Charles in O, The Oprah Magazine

The Reaction
"My friends and family did double takes when they saw me. Some people couldn't put their finger on the change—they just said, 'Wow, you look younger!' In retrospect, all that gray really wasn't serving me well. Now I look as vibrant and full of energy as I feel. And the home coloring process was so much easier than I thought it would be!"

(Don't want to cover your grey? See how eight women took their grey to great!)
Irina Belkovskaya in O, the Oprah Magazine

The Goal: Lighten Up
Irina Belkovskaya, 26
She was a full-on blonde for a few years, but when we met her, Irina, a student, had scaled back to only a handful of subtle blonde highlights in her light brown hair. She'd never done her own color and was curious to see if she could go all-over blonde again without a trip to the salon."

The Lesson Plan

"Going lighter at home can be a little tricky because in order to get an even blonde from roots to ends, you can't use the same color all over," says Sharon. That's because when you're going lighter, the heat from your scalp causes the color to process more quickly near the roots. Sharon had Irina use one color through the midlength of her hair (L'Oréal Superior Preference in Light Ash Blonde, $9, drugstores) and then go a shade lighter (L'Oréal Superior Preference in Lightest Ash Blonde, $9, drugstores) on the ends.

See Irina's results
Irina Belkovskaya in O, the Oprah Magazine

The Reaction
"I was hoping for a brighter blonde; this shade is a little too strawberry for me. But it's fun to try something different, and I can always go back to my old color—though I'm not sure if I'll be brave enough to do it without Sharon standing next to me!"

Your Home Haircolor Tool Kit