Black Eyeliner

Photo: Courtesy of Revlon

2 of 5
Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner in Black
"I've never been good with eyeliner," admits assistant beauty editor Alessandra Foresto, "but this pencil glides on so easily, I can create a perfect line on the first try." And while the waterproof formula lasts for hours without smudging, she doesn't have to scrub to get it off.