Tyler Lepley and Peter Parros

2 of 6
After putting his clothes on, Benny comes out of the bedroom and quickly makes up an excuse to explain why he has David's truck. He tells David the half-truth that Veronica had been drinking the night she sprung him from jail and that she had asked Benny to drive.

To Benny's relief, David accepts his story and takes the keys to the vehicle. But Benny may not be off the hook yet—when David gets inside his truck to drive away, he notices handprints all over the glass.