Devastated Mom Speaks Out After One Her Twins Dies at Sitter's House

Aired on 11/11/1997 | CC tv-pg
Twins Bobby and Toby Casey had their whole lives ahead of them, to grow and to laugh, to play together. But their shared dreams ended on a January day in 1995. The Caseys had dropped the boys off at a baby-sitter's home. That afternoon, the baby-sitter, Arlene Hatcher, called their mother, Elisa Casey, back to the house. When Elisa got there, 13-month-old Toby was unconscious. He had been brutally shaken. Here, an emotional Elisa shares why she feels justice was not served in her case.