Photo: Gregor Halenda

9 of 14
Guilding the Cookie
Belgian chocolate cheesecake is sandwiched between chocolate all-butter shortbread hearts, while strawberry cheesecake fills the vanilla pair. Both are hand-dipped in pink chocolate and dusted with sprinkles. Somewhere a Keebler elf is weeping.
  • Eli's Cheesecake of Chicago heart-shaped cookie sandwiches, originally $39 for six, now 20 percent off with code OPRAH

    Available at: