Photo: Gregor Halenda

2 of 9
Best for: The Hostess
Josephine's Feast! Spreads
Made from local produce in small batches—each jar has about two pounds of fruit and nothing artificial—these distinctive and delicious, not-too-sweet spreads from Long Island come in flavors like Ginger-Spiced Carrot Jam with Drunken Raisins and Red Hot Pepper Jam.