Photo: Marko Metzinger/Studio D

7 of 7
Love Potions
Duke Cannon Big American, Grown Alchemist Vanilla & Watermelon Lip Balm and Penhaligon's Bayolea Eau de Toilette
I always choose gifts that I'd love to get myself, which is why I'm giving my valentine these three (should he care to share—and he should): an oversize bar of Duke Cannon Big American soap, with an invigorating bergamot and black pepper scent; organic Grown Alchemist Vanilla and Watermelon Lip Balm; and the refreshing Penhaligon's Bayolea Eau de Toilette, with unisex notes of mandarin and sandalwood, isn't love a many-splendored thing?
—Valerie Monroe, O Beauty Director