Oprah eats a catfish sloppy joe.

5 of 14
After Gayle's glowing review, Rick hops a flight to Chicago to prepare his culinary creation for Oprah—complete with the sandwich's surprising potato chip and pickle toppings.

Get the recipe and make this sandwich at home!

Oprah's ready to take the taste bud challenge. "I've had a lot of catfish in my life," she says. "That is really good." On a scale of 1 to 5, Oprah gives the sandwich a 6! "[It's] about to be a 7."

Gayle's also ready to be generous. "On my little sandwich rating, I'm going to give this 4 out of 5," she says.