A Study in Scarlet Women

3 of 5
A Study in Scarlet Women
336 pages; Berkley
Reboots and new takes on Sherlock Holmes seem to appear every week, but Sherry Thomas' twist is particularly smart and captivating. Here, "Sherlock" is a cover for Charlotte Holmes, an observant and ambitious young woman eager to escape the strictures of upper-crust London society, which expects nothing more from her than to marry well. Thomas, taking a detour from her best-selling historical romances to launch her Lady Sherlock series with this book, hits all the Victorian-sleuth pleasure points, giving her heroine practically every Holmesian feature but the pipe and deerstalker cap. Charlotte is a keen cataloger of small details—a swatch of clothing, an unopened curtain—which reveal volumes about a puzzling crime. And she has a juicy mystery to solve involving the murders of three wealthy figures. However, beyond her well-researched details about hansom cabs and the devious uses of arsenic, Thomas helps you understand a Victorian reality: A woman's reputation could explode in an instant, leading her scrabbling to survive. Witty, fast-paced, with a charismatic heroine who surprises and delights.
— Mark Athitakis