When Karie got Jeanne's call, she hurried to her sister's house to get online and confirm that William C. Davis, the man featured on the Oprah Show, was indeed her upstairs neighbor—who she knew by his alias, Mark Davis. "Sure enough," Karie says, "his picture popped up and I shook so bad I dumped my coffee over."
Soon after confirming Mark's true identity, Karie went back to her duplex, where she crossed paths with Davis. "I had his picture folded up that I had printed off the website in my pocket. As I was walking up the steps [of the duplex], he's coming out his door." Karie, afraid Davis would sense her fear, tried to maintain her composure and didn't object when Davis followed her inside her home for a meal of macaroni and cheese. Davis had no idea FBI agents were on their way to make the arrest.