For years, Laurie has hidden her long toes in clunky black shoes, but now it's time to let them breathe! "You have to own up to your toes," Mary Alice says. "We're going to decorate your foot, and you're going to fall in love with your foot again."

Mary Alice chooses a pair of suede peep-toe heels for Laurie. "Suede is really good for you because it just kind of molds to your feet," she says. "And peep toe, now this is disguising that area you don't like."

These Nine West heels are in gray, one of the hottest colors this fall.

Nine West Bonfire heels in Gray Suede;Zappos.com