Black and brown eyeliner addict and online health and fitness editor Corrie Pikul tried a different shade of these soft, creamy colored pencils every day for a week. "I was afraid the ultrabright colors would make me look like I was going to a rave, but a light swipe across my upper lashlines was all I needed to give my brown eyes a boost." Plus, they stayed put even after hitting the gym. Pikul likes the blue and purple, but if you prefer something more understated, try one of the metallic colors for a soft and shimmery look.
$5 each, NYXCosmetics.com