Step 1: Maneuvering a full strip of lashes is tricky, so Carmindy recommends cutting the strip in half with cuticle scissors. Gayle used Andrea Modlash #33. (For a less full fringe, try #53, $3.50 each; Drugstore.com.)
Our December issue features Oprah's Favorite Things—as well as your chance to win them all! You'll also find our easy holiday declutter plan, Dr. Oz's guide to sleeping better (starting tonight) and the ultimate holiday menu.