5 Products Beauty Editors Wear Down to the Nub

Fresh Sugar Plum Tinted Lip Treatment SPF 15

This balm is the perfect hybrid of a lipstick and a gloss, plus it hydrates like nobody's business—hence the reason executive beauty editor Jenny Bailly is officially addicted. "It leaves the perfect berry stain," she says, "and it's waxy enough that the color sticks around for a while."

$23; Sephora.com