Just two years after appearing on the show, Libby and Chris split. "She was the one," Chris says. "It came to an end, and that's all right. And hopefully we can be friends in the future."

After the breakup, Chris dated a man for a time. Still, she does not want to label herself as gay or bisexual. "If I'm capable of having intimacy with a man, then that means probably that I'm not gay," she says. "However, when it comes to relationships and where I'm most comfortable, I prefer to be with women."