The day of taping, all five talk show hosts arrive, giddy with excitement. "The thing I loved about all our talk show hosts is they were just genuinely happy to be here," Jill says. "And then they're taking pictures and passing around their cameras and I'm taking pictures for them. To be a part of that, the energy was electric in the building."

Watch their arrivals 

When Phil arrives, he gets the rockstar treatment from Harpo staff—and all the other hosts. "We're a little more excited to meet you than any celebrity that's been on," Jill says. "Somehow it all does start with you."

"I'm happy to have been somehow responsible," Phil says. "I'm pleased to be thought of as the father of these illegitimate children—they know I'm teasing."

When it's time for taping, Jill admits she's a little nervous. "With five talk show hosts on the air there's no telling how it's going to go."