The pressure mounts as the team tries to locate townspeople who appeared on the first show to find out if their views have changed. As the team digs deeper, they realize this is no easy task—not everyone, it seems, feels differently now than they did back then.

"The worst thing in my mind that could happen is we shoot and bring Oprah and no one has an epiphany," co-producer Bridgette says. "I do not believe Oprah wants to have the same show."