Later that night, Oprah hosts a champagne toast for the team in her office.

Watch the celebration

"That moment when Oprah is toasting our team and saying this was her favorite surprise, it's surreal," Brian says. "Because you don't think growing up that you'll be standing in Oprah Winfrey's office one day with her toasting you with a glass of champagne."

Exclusive webisode: Go to happy hour with Jenna and Brian

See what happens when the Judds return to The Oprah Show

Get more inside secrets from The Oprah Show staff