"We had to get you," Jamie says.
Gary and Jamie say they concocted the surprise with Oprah show producers—despite the fact that Oprah isn't a fan of surprises. The group just couldn't resist giving Oprah an unexpected holiday treat. "Jamie and ourselves did this song on our new record, and we know how big of a fan you are of Jamie," Gary says. "So, Merry Christmas! Happy New Year! Happy Thanksgiving!"