"It's the brand new 2012 Volkswagen Beetle!" Oprah says.
See all of Oprah's Ultimate Favorite Things
"Oh my gosh, thank you," Justin says. "I can't believe this!"
The audience also won't be leaving empty-handed—thanks to Citi, each audience member is going home with 25,000 Thank You Points, which can be redeemed for flights, dining out and more.