Before they started filming Bewitched, Will says he was a little nervous about meeting Nicole for the first time. That is, until the topic turned to his revealing role in Old School.
"I was in New York and you were working on The Stepford Wives. [Bewitched director] Nora Ephron called me up at the last second and was like, 'Come on, we've got to go meet Nicole. Let's go right now. I want to get you guys in a room [together],'" Will tells Nicole. "So we had like five minutes because you were about to go start shooting again. ... We were both, like, 'Hello. How are you?' And then I just started talking...and you said, 'I just saw Old School. I thought it was very funny.' And then there was a big silence and you just started laughing. So I said, 'What? Are you thinking about my butt right now?'"