All-American Tragedy

Six years after the Baby Boy Hope unsolved mystery, Jessica no longer dated Tom and was now in a serious relationship with Matt. One night, while out at a bar, Jessica and Matt were talking about their future together.

"All of a sudden, I had a nervous breakdown, and I just started crying. I started talking about what had happened," Jessica says. "Someone had overheard me. This person made an anonymous call to Detective Yost which led to him questioning me."

Detective Yost says the caller was "very specific" and "very certain" that Jessica was the mother of the found baby, and he went to interview her.