SEE OUR UPDATED LIST OF BEST SELF-TANNERS FOR 2012
Best for Control Freaks
Aveeno Continuous Radiance Moisturizing Lotion ($15)
The dual-chamber bottle has lotion on one side, self-tanner on the other; a dial lets you slowly amp up to a bronze glow. Click up one level every morning, and after five days you'll have eased into a sun-kissed tint.