|
Sign up for our newsletters!
Subscribe to O, The Oprah Magazine
Now What Do I Do?

Defacing Hummers - Ethics Advice

Q: My environmentalist friend likes to put bumper stickers on Hummers that say, I'm Ruining the Environment—Ask Me How! I know she should stop, but doesn't a gas guzzler do more harm than a bumper sticker?

A: What a terrible argument! Defacing someone's personal property because you don't approve of their priorities is simply vandalism and harassment, and accomplishes nothing positive at all.
— Jack Marshall, president, ProEthics

What's wrong isn't the bumper sticker—which is pretty funny—but the smug self-approval and feel-goodism behind it. If she has even a small car, isn't she also wrecking the atmosphere? Or suppose she's pro-choice: Is she okay with someone pasting a pro-life sticker on her suede jacket? You don't deface property to trumpet your ideals.
— Rushworth M. Kidder, founder, the Institute for Global Ethics

It's not just wrong, it's what we lawyers call a tort—specifically, a trespass to chattel. Your friend owes a lot of people for any damage done to the cars she's chosen to "decorate." If she feels like interfering with other people's property, a flyer under the windshield wiper might be a better form of protest.
— Anita L. Allen, professor of law and philosophy, the University of Pennsylvania Law School

From the April 2008 issue of O, The Oprah Magazine
Loading...
Advertisement
Advertisement
IN THE CURRENT ISSUE
In our June issue you'll find 7 steps to creating the life you really want and Oprah's soul-searching journey with a spiritual master—plus much more.
see all new stories
Advertisement