Failure rate*: 0.3–9%
Who: Women who are happy with the pill but have trouble remembering to take it every day.
- After it's inserted, women can forget about it for the next three weeks.
- The lower dose of estrogen means that side effects (like facial hyperpigmentation) tend to be less noticeable.
- Some women find that the ring also makes their periods shorter and lighter.
- As noted on the NuvaRing inserts, cardiovascular risks may be higher with the ring than with some pills—especially for smokers and women over 35.
- Carusi says that a lot of younger women are uncomfortable about getting personal with their vaginas, and the ring involves hands-on attention. Long fingernails can be a liability.
- It occasionally makes its presence known during sex—and sometimes even slips out. To remain effective, it then needs to be rinsed with lukewarm water and reinserted within three hours.
- "Many women think it's too expensive," says Carusi (co-pays vary, but the average cost is $34). Unlike the pill, the NuvaRing isn't available in a discounted generic version.