Photo: Gregor Halenda

89 of 101
Winner, Winner, Chicken Dinner
Centerville Pies Signature Chicken Pie
"I found this chicken pie on Cape Cod years ago, and it's still the closest to homemade I've ever tasted. The hand-crimped crust is flaky, the filling is jam-packed with hand-pulled meat, and the people who make them are clearly doing so with love." —Oprah