Who they're for: Everyone you like but don't know well enough to buy socks for.
Why they'll love them: Three Tarts cookies taste exactly—exactly—the way perfect homemade Christmas cookies should taste. Buttery, tender, crisp, sweet. The hammered-silver-plate box contains nine different kinds, from mixed-berry Linzer cookies to almond-chocolate "yum balls," and can be reused all year.
$75 for 26 treats in silver box
Available at: 3Tarts.com