Not unless she's dressed up! "I'm in a ponytail, glasses and my sweatpants at the grocery store, and people won't [ask] me, 'Are you Carrie Underwood?'" she says. "They'll say, 'Wow, you look like Carrie Underwood,' because Carrie Underwood wouldn't be at the Harris Teeter, you know, 11 o'clock at night in her sweatpants."

Catch up with country's biggest star—Kenny Chesney!

Darius Rucker's country debut

Why country music is sweeter with Sugarland