BD: One of the things that comes with being on American Idol is recognition. Tell us about the first time you were recognized for being on the show.

LR: After the Kansas City auditions were aired and Memphis got a chance to kind of see my audition and everything, I went out to [the grocery store] Kroger and I walked in and then I just walked around, went down a couple of aisles and so, but then I saw people whispering.

BD: I couldn't even imagine getting mobbed in a grocery store. That's crazy!

LR: It was really—I'm like "Oh my God, I cannot believe this is happening in Kroger."