producerji's Blog

by producerji
Description: As a producer of Oprah's Book Club, reading of all kinds is my job and my passion!
Posts (16) 1 2 | Next

Are You One of Them? RSVP Now for Our Web Event!

Posted on Oct 30, 2009 12:52 PM

On Monday, November 9th...

Oprah.com and CNN.com present...

Oprah's Book Club Worldwide Web Event

Oprah and author Uwem Akpan will be discussing his book, Say You're One of Them

To R.S.V.P. for this LIVE webcast -- click on the link below:

http://www.oprah.com/static/webcast/cnn/webcast_register_cnn.html

READ A SHORT STORY - FOR FREE!

And for those you who read this blog but haven't read the book -- we understand, life is busy, so we have something special just for you! When you RSVP for the webcast you'll be able to download the first story of the collection, "An Ex-mas Feast."

Now you don't even have to leave your house to check out this selection... All you have to do RSVP for our web event. How great is that!!!

We really wanted you to check out this not-to-be-missed book. Because after you read this first story -- you'll want to check out the whole collection, I promise!

ARE YOU ONE OF THEM?

Now that we've discussed each story in this collection, what does the title of this book mean to you?

The title is from "My Parent's Bedroom," the last story of the book and one that is set during the Rwandan Genocide.

On a night that will alter the course of her young life forever, nine year old Monique has this conversation with her mother:

"'When they ask you,' she says sternly, without looking at me, ‘say you're one of them, OK?'

‘Who?'

‘Anybody.'"

"Who" do we really belong to? In some way we all belong to a group whether it's a family unit, a religious affiliation, or a cultural or ethnic identity... a "tribe" so to speak. And belonging to a group often gives us a way to find comfort, community, and success in managing the world. But I would suggest that when we get our whole identify from a group, when we chose to view the rest of world as "us and them" -- we lose our humanity. We ignore the common human connection we have for each other. And I believe this why we have the poverty, crime, and devastation we see here and around the world.

Monique's mother was giving her daughter a final lesson on how to survive. I think Monique's mother knew what many others know about the world -- that if you are actually being asked the question, "Who do you belong to?"... making the wrong choice could be dangerous and even deadly.

But I choose to see the title another way. After reading this collection of stories of children suffering at the hands of adults... I know that there is no "us and them." I feel this title is actually a call to action for me. I am one of these children and they are me. I AM ONE OF THEM. And what I know for certain is that when we stop and take the time to see our human bonds instead of our cultural, social, economic, political, and even physical differences... we create a moment of peace in the world.

What does the title of this book mean to you?

What do you want to ask our author?

13 Comments
 

We Walk Forward: The Final and Ultimate Lesson

Posted on Oct 23, 2009 5:44 PM

First - Our Big Book Club News....

We're excited to announce that for the first time ever -- Oprah.com is joining forces with CNN.com to present a very special LIVE Book Cub Web Event on Monday, November 9th at 9pm EST, 8pm CST.

Oprah and author Uwem Akpan will be discussing his book, Say You're One of Them. We'll be taking your questions and calls during the program and we want to hear what you have to say!

To R.S.V.P. for our web event -- click on the link below:

http://www.oprah.com/static/webcast/cnn/webcast_register_cnn.html

And if you have a burning question for our author -- send it to us and you might get to ask it yourself during our broadcast:

https://www.oprah.com/plugform.jsp?plugId=2902689

Now onto the last short story of this collection, "My Parents' Bedroom"...

After finishing this story, the question that has been running through my mind is: At what moment did you leave your childhood behind?

There's a time in almost every child's life when he or she has an abrupt entry into the adult world. As a child of an alcoholic father, I think about the number of things I should not have seen or experienced so young. For many children their particular event was so traumatic that their psyches might take years, sometimes even a lifetime, to heal. This story makes me think about all the children who go to bed hungry night after night, who are orphaned too young by their parents' death from AIDS, are the innocent victims of wars, or have family circumstances that robbed them of their childhood at a very young age. I often wonder if these children will ever get over what they've lived through and find a way to survive.

I think the answer can be found at the end of the story when nine year old Monique, having witnessed something no child or human being for that matter should ever see -- decides to do the one thing we all can do, if we chose, when faced with so much trauma.

"There are corpses everywhere. Their clothes are dancing in the wind." (page 353)

The adults in the story are caught up in a deadly frenzy of chaos and violence -- what the rest of the world would eventually learned of in 1994 as the Rwandan Genocide. Before I read this book I never imagined what it was like for the children of that modern day holocaust, but in this story Monique is there as our witness. And she dutifully reports what the adults do after their grotesque killing spree in her home, "They run on."

Yet it's what Monique says she does next, with her baby brother in tow, that I think is the most profound event of the story. Monique tells us quite simply, after all of the anguish and suffering she has experienced, "we walk forward." Her statement is an intention, a directive of purpose and I believe, an act of forgiveness.

What Monique chooses to do demonstrates what we all can try to do when faced with life's challenges... we can walk forward, we can walk through, and we can simply forgive. I believe the end of this story is telling us not to get caught in the swirl of anger and violence, or even in the question of why. I believe our author is trying to offer an instruction to the reader on the way past grief, hurt, and suffering. He's perhaps trying to teach us that there really is a way out of the pain of our past. And the way is to forgive... to walk forward. If Monique can put one foot in front of the other -- and not look back -- then maybe so can we.

What do you think after you finished this story? How did it help you see your life and your world in a new way? Is there anyone you need to forgive?

14 Comments
 

A Hearse to Nowhere

Posted on Oct 16, 2009 10:04 PM

In the news today there's story about a judge in Louisiana who refused to marriage an interracial couple. Yes, this is in the national news TODAY... not 1959, but in 2009... in the United States of America.

Reportedly the judge told the Associate Press he wasn't racist, he just didn't believe in mixing the races "in that way."

This incident made me think about "Luxurious Hearses" -- story #4 in our current book club selection, Say You're One of Them, by Uwem Akpan -- in a very new way.


And what's so interesting for me is that up until today, I believed that the cultural disdain around the marriage of Jubril's (the main character) parents, a Muslim woman and Nigerian Christian, was something that we have moved past in this country. Not only in the legal arena since the 1967 landmark Supreme Court Case of Loving v. Virginia (which found the Commonwealth of Virginia's ban on interracial marriage unconstitutional), but even more significantly - socially. I thought we had moved beyond the kinds of attitudes and conflicts represented in the story at least in a public sense (and not in terms of gay marriage, but that's the next social and cultural frontier for this country). I thought what takes place in this short story is what happens "over there," not here. Of course the exact circumstances and certainly the level of racial and cultural violence in "Luxurious Hearses" isn't going on today in America, but what I assume could no longer take place in my country... just did today.


The stories in Say You're One of Them all involve children in peril in Africa. I think it's easy for us here in the U.S. to think about these tragic situations as occurring only on the African continent. But I challenge readers to think of these stories as a reflection of "us" in terms of the human condition. And whereas the situations might be different depending on where we live, the underlying themes in this collection unite us all in a bigger and greater way. I believe that the genius of this book, and all good books, is that they allow us -- if we are willing -- to see our own world in a new and more honest way.


After I finished this story I went back and read the quote Father Uwem selected as its epigraph (page 187). They are truly words to live by:


Argue not with the People of the Book unless it be in a better way, except with such of them as do wrong; and say: "We believe in that which has been revealed to us and revealed to you; our God and your God is One, and to God we surrender." --Koran 29:46


What did you think after reading "Luxurious Hearses"? Did this story allow you to see something in your own life or the world in a new way? Let me know what you think!

16 Comments
 

Did You Ever Have A BFF?

Posted on Oct 14, 2009 4:28 PM

I've been reading your comments on this blog and on the book club message boards and have been quite moved by your thoughts and insights about this book. I've noticed that many of you are asking now that you've read this book and your eyes have been opened to what it's really like for those in need, how you can help. Many of us here felt the same way when we read Say You're One of Them and that's why we decided to create a section on this site on how to make a difference.

For those of you interested in finding out ways to help, please take a look at our "For All Women Registry." We have selected a variety of programs that do the vital work of helping women and children in need around the world.

http://www.oprah.com/article/oprahsbookclub/pastselections/pkguwemakpan/20090930-obc-say-youre-one-of-them-charity

And if you're wondering why this registry is for women and girls, it's because we've learned that they are the key to changing the world for the better. We have been educated by people like Pulitzer Prize winners Nicholas Kristof and Sheryl WuDunn who together wrote an extraordinary new book, Half the Sky, featured on our show a few weeks ago. They say that when you help a mother and a girl, you help the whole family not just survive but thrive - and that's exactly why we created our Oprah.com registry. I hope you take a moment to look at the programs we highlighted.

Now for those who've read story #3, "What Language Is That?" - my question to you is... "Did you ever have a BFF (Best Friend Forever)?" I did when I was in elementary school. Her name was Katy and I thought she was sheer perfection. She was the very first friend I made when my parents moved us from the south side of Chicago to a leafy suburban neighborhood in Evanston, IL. She was my same age and lived across the street from me and I wanted to do everything Katy did. We spent all our time together: we played dress up and listened to music on her cool record player and talked and talked and talked. She was white with curly blonde hair that looked like an afro and I was the only 7 year old black girl in the neighborhood. She never hesitated to be my friend and her parents welcomed my family to the area and into their home.

But that was not the case for some of the families who lived on our neighboring blocks. The ones next door made it known that my brother, younger sister, and I were not allowed in their house or yard and several others families followed suit. My parents had worked with a fair housing organization to buy the house we lived in and I guess in 1970s suburbia, racial equality for some had not moved from the lunch counter to the front porch. At the time Katy and I didn't think we were remarkable, but I guess to the adult world we were an example that seemed to many unfathomable and to some... undesirable.

Eventually Katy and I drifted apart on our own once we got to junior high and the social culture of race caught up to both of us. But I will always be grateful that I had that kind of special friendship and that we both had and for parents who unlike the ones in the book, could look beyond our differences to see that true friendship is a human -- not racial, religious or cultural -- bond.

What did you think when you read, "What Language Is That?" How did this story make you think of your own life or the world differently? I can't wait to read your thoughts!

19 Comments
 

The Story That Haunts My Dreams

Posted on Oct 3, 2009 11:30 AM

First of all, if you haven't seen it already - please check out Oprah's video blog which she'll do for each story of our current book club selection, Say You're One of Them by Uwem Akpan:

http://www.oprah.com/media/20090923-obc-oprah-video-blog

I suggest you start with her first blog and agree with Oprah that it's best to read the stories in order. I think you'll find that each story in some way informs the next. And if you are just finishing the first story of the book, check out my previous blog where I'll be having an on-going story discussion about "An Ex-mas Feast."

Oprah's newest blog is on the second story of the book, "Fattening for Gabon." For me, this story read like a fevered dream, one that was forever seared into my brain: those innocent children, the suffocating hut, the morally unbalanced Fofo Kpee, and that brilliant opening line, "Selling your children or nephew could be more difficult than selling other kids."

Actually, this story felt less like a dream and more like a nightmare. There's one nightmare in particular I get from time to time where something terrible happens and I can't move my legs to run and when I open my mouth to shout, I have no voice. I am completely and utterly helpless -- all I can do is watch what's happening in front of my eyes.

That's what it was like for me as I was reading this story -- I couldn't confront the adults, I couldn't tell the children to flee... helpless to stop the inevitable, all I could do was read on. All I could do was bear witness. And perhaps by reading this book in some way I'm bearing witness for all the other children in horrific circumstances all over this world. Because after reading this collection -- now I do know, and on some very deep plane, I will never be the same.

And after I finished the last page of the story (don't read any further if you haven't finished)... I am haunted by these questions: Did Kotchikpa, the brother, make the right decision to flee leaving his younger sister behind? Should he have stayed so his sister did not have to face such a terrible future alone?

I ask you: What do you think? What would you have done? Was Fofo Kpee a villain or victim of his economic circumstances? How did this story change you?

20 Comments
 

Ex-mas on the Streets of Nairobi

Posted on Oct 3, 2009 11:25 AM

As promised, I'm blogging about the first story of our current book club selection, Say You're One of Them by Uwem Akpan, titled "An Ex-mas Feast." If you haven't finished the story, I suggest you do before you read this -- you'll get much more out of it, I promise.

I'm first struck by the pure irony of the setting: a family celebrating a Christmas holiday on the street because they have nowhere better to go, much like Mary and Joseph -- but they at least found a manger. And instead being surrounding by animals and sleeping on straw, the family of this story live in filth and squalor in a rundown shack.

And then the mother, hungover from partying night before, gives her children glue in order to keep their hunger at bay. This was where I stopped and thought, am I up for this? Can I handle the destitution and heartbreak on these pages? I really didn't know if I could -- it was a particularly beautiful day outside... there were plenty of errands to run.... But after the first couple of pages, all I did know was that I could not put the book down.

I needed to know, do these children in this story even have a chance? They live in utter destitution with parents who have given up the fight to better themselves, change their circumstances, completely. But then I think there's hope for these children because they have each other. Maisha is working as a prostitute so her family will have enough money for her eight-year-old brother, Jigana, to attend school for the first time. And Jigana is as devoted to his sister as she is to him. That to me is survival on the edge of despair -- right there, in my face -- who am I to look away.

In some way, it reminds me of my own family's story about the time my mother dropped out of college so her younger sister could go to nursing school. They didn't have much money; my grandfather had a devastating stroke and could no longer work, so my mother quit school to go to work to help. My mother's family was nowhere near the dire straits of the family in the story, but it was 1940s America and they were struggling, not just to survive... but also achieve. And I guess why this family story has stayed with me is that my mother never had a moment of resentment about dropping out, not once. I could never understand why. She was as smart as her sister and was just as deserving, but after reading this story, I now understand.

My mother didn't just see herself as an individual, but as part of a unit, whose success relied on someone, anyone in fact, getting to the next rung. And when that person succeeded, everyone else felt they did too. That was how families fought their ways out of poverty, sacrifices had to be made and everyone understood. In our case it worked. My mother went on to eventually finish college and even achieve a Masters Degree.

But sometimes the burden is too much to bear, the weight too heavy. And in the case of this story -- a tsunami wave of pain and despair swept Maisha and Jigana out on the dangerous streets of Nairobi unmoored and all alone. Will they end up like their own parents, discarded like detritus from a city that never saw their value? Parents who might have been like Maisha and Jigana in their youth? Or will each of them find their own path to a better life than the one they knew?

All I do know is that when I see children begging in the streets again... I will think stop and differently -- and that's what a great story is there to do.

What are your thoughts about "Ex-mas Feast"? Will these children survive? Are the parents at fault or victims of a system that doesn't support those who have the least? I can't wait to read what you have to say!

19 Comments
 

We Have A New Book Club Selection!

Posted on Oct 3, 2009 11:24 AM

We announced our new book selection, Say You're One of Them by Uwem Akpan, on Friday, September 18th, 2009. As Oprah said, it's like no other book we've picked before -- it's our first collection of short stories!!! Tell me what you think of our pick. Have you read it before? Are you a fan of short stories?

And, thank you for all your books suggestions over the past few weeks. Please let us know your thoughts on this new book!

We'll be discussing the first story, "An Ex-mas Feast," here next week.

38 Comments
 

The One Question I'm Always Asked Is....

Posted on Oct 3, 2009 11:21 AM

Actually it's two questions I'm always asked....

The first is:

"What's your next book?"

Of course I can't answer that question - but Oprah will LIVE on the show next Friday, September 18th, 2009! It's been a long time since we've had a selection so we're extremely excited, too. It's always an exhilarating time around here in bookclubland when we have a new selection.

And, thank you all for posting titles on my last blog of what you'd like to see as future book club selections. It's great to see what our members recommend so feel free at any time throughout this season to post your suggestions.

Now the other question I get most of all is:

"How do I submit a book to Oprah's Book Club?"

Here's the deal, our book club is like any other in the way that we find books on our own through lots of research and word-of-mouth. That being the case, we don't accept submissions from authors -- but we deeply appreciate all the authors who are interested in being a part of our book club and all the hard work they dedicate to their art. So if you're an author and have a published book you'd like us to check out, free feel to post the title and/or cut and paste your book review to your post.

Let the countdown to our new season AND new book begin....

100 Comments
 

We Have a New Book!

Posted on Oct 3, 2009 11:10 AM

In case you missed it - Oprah tweeted this week with some BIG book club news:

"Hey all you Book Clubbers. Tune in Friday, September 18th to find out what my new book club pick is-never made a selection like ‘this'."

We're all very excited around here. And, we're happy to see that so many people all over the web are trying to guess the title - it's exciting to see how much our readers love a mystery! But our lips are sealed so stay tuned...

And if you have any titles you'd like to guess or just suggest, please do send them our way!

Now for my thoughts on Middlemarch:

BOOK ONE: Miss Brooks

It takes me only a few pages to fall in love with the main character, Dorothea Brooks. Maybe I do because she reminds me of myself in some way - not the exceptional beauty part - but her pursuit of ideas that were not considered appropriate feminine interest. As the daughter of a scientist and mathematic, my father always encouraged me to pursue fields that - even as late as the 1970s - were consider strictly male. As more and more girls dropped out of my high school math and science classes, I continued on, not understanding why they didn't feel the thrill of scientific thinking and logic as I did. But when two of the most popular girls in the school asked me to be in their study group for chemistry class - I jumped at the chance to find some kind of feminine bond and social status. And when they decided it wasn't worth the effort to study for the final exam, I decided it wasn't either. I received a score I knew my efforts deserved but wounded my ego. In the end, that was the emotional catalyst* I needed to learn that all-important "passage of youth into maturity" lesson of being your own person in the face of social convention.

Okay, so I found a way to make the book all about me. Satisfied, I move on to part 2. But not before I also fall in love with Fred, the bon vivant brother of Rosamond whose rakish charm I feel will come to no good. I have to root for him anyway - perhaps the love of a grounded good woman like Mary Garth will bring out the best of him....

*Per Webster's and my high school science curriculum:

CATALYST: 1) a substance that enables a chemical reaction to proceed at a usually faster rate or under different conditions (as at a lower temperature) than otherwise possible. 2) an agent that provokes or speeds significant change or action.

BOOK 2: Old and Young

I'm all excited to meet Lydgate and read about the medical controversies of the day (there's a line about a legal reform regarding doctors and druggists which reminds me of a familiar debate about the relationship of pharmaceutical companies and doctors). When I get to the part about Lydgate's dangerous attraction to an actress who's accused of murdering her husband on-stage, I cannot put the book down! But that feeling passes as I read every footnotes (which I like having) in my edition (Bantam Classic) -- and slowing make my way to the end of this section.

I do remember reading somewhere that Eliot was criticized in her day about her inclusion of scientific subject matter. And as I'm reading I keep trying to wrap my brain around the fact that such a brilliant woman of the Victoria Era, with all that goes with being a women of that time, had the fortitude and perseverance to go against such overwhelming cultural convention to write her OWN story, not the one she was expected to tell. I guess learning to be your own person - or "standing in your truth" as Oprah often says on the show - is a lesson that transcends Victorian conventions and high school science labs and speaks to the universality of the human condition.

35 Comments
 

I Have a Confession To Make....

Posted on Aug 21, 2009 12:15 PM

Okay, I could dance around this confession for a paragraph or two blabbing about my summer vacation and all, but let me get right to it. I said I was going to read a classic this summer and with your help I chose Middlemarch by George Eliot. Right away, I downloaded it on my Kindle, got a variety of paperback versions just in case and hit the beach with good intentions but.... I have to confess; I didn't stick to the reading schedule and have NOT finished the book. Okay, I said it - it feels good to get this book guilt off my chest. I apologize to all who committed to reading along with me. I WAY over-estimated my capacity to read a classic book and about 7 or 8 other titles at the same time. I tend to use my summer breaks as a way to read as many books as possible as potential selections; I didn't factor in what an extra 1,000 pages would do to my reading schedule.

But in the end, I'm glad I tackled Middlemarch and here's what I learned from attempting such a great classic:


1. Classics require your full attention.

Unlike many a modern book that breezes along with cultural references and conversational dialogue, classics are set in a historic place and time and understanding this new world requires time and concentration. So, trying to read while eating my way through Europe was not a good way to start.

2. Classics can have footnotes - if you're lucky!

I happen to pick a very small print paperback edition that I got attached to very quickly because it had footnotes explaining many of the references I didn't understand. But the type was small and my eyes are over 40 so it was really, really slow going.

3. Classics still have lessons for readers today.

Unlike many books I read quickly and never think of again once I'm done, classics are not only stories that stand the test of time but have something of value to say about the human condition that is still relevant and timely. What I loved about Middlemarch - at least the parts I finished, is that the debate about love, medicine, science, power, marriage are all topics we still discuss and examine today.

So in order to get back on track - I will be discussing the book as I move through it, albeit slowly. My next blog will be Parts 1 & 2 of Middlemarch. For all of you who are already done with the novel and followed the reading schedule - you get an A+ - and I hope you join in on the discussion. And for the rest of us bringing up the rear, summer's not over yet - let's get reading!

32 Comments
 

Summer Reading Schedule

Posted on Jun 12, 2009 11:34 PM

We're reading Middlemarch by George Eliot this summer! So, hit you local library, bookstore, or even your friends and family for any edition of this classic novel and read along with us over the next few months.

Here's our schedule:

You'll have a week to read each chapter in advance and on the Friday listed below, I'll be blogging my thoughts on the book so far and eagerly waiting to hear what you think too:

June 12th: Get reading!
June 19th: Prelude & Book 1
June 26th: Book 2
July 3rd: Book 3
July 10th: Book 4
July 17th: Book 5
July 24th: Book 6
July 31st: Book 7
August 7th: Book 8 & Finale

Middlemarch
by George Eliot
Book Description:
Bright, beautiful, and rebellious Dorothea has married the wrong man, and Lydgate--the ambitious new doctor in town--has married the wrong woman. Both of them long to make a positive difference in the world, but their lives do not proceed as expected. Along with the other inhabitants of Middlemarch, they must struggle to reconcile themselves to their fates and find their places in the world. (Vintage Classics)

Now -- for all you readers looking for a new book to read over the summer, I encourage you to check out O, The Oprah Magazine's Books of Summer. It's a fantastic list of 25 titles for every kind of readers:

http://www.oprah.com/article/oprahsbookclub/readinglists/pkgsummerreading/200907-omag-summer-reading-list

And, for our younger readers -- school's almost out and we've updated our kids reading list which has some great recommendations from the American Library Association:

http://www.oprah.com/article/oprahsbookclub/kidsreadinglist/pkgkidsreadinglist/20080701_orig_kids_books

Stayed tuned to my blog this summer for our Middlemarch book discussion -- I can't wait to get started and hear what you have to say! And, you can also follow me on Twitter.com where I'll also be "tweeting" my book thoughts whenever the inspiration hits. Find me at "Jada110."

Lastly -- what else are you reading this summer? Send me your book titles -- I'd love to check them out!!!

Happy Summer Reading!

68 Comments
 

AND THE WINNING TITLE IS......

Posted on Jun 5, 2009 2:41 PM

I'd like to thank everyone who participated and sent me your choice for the classic book I should read this summer. There were a lot of suggestions -- some I've read before like Pride and Prejudice, Atlas Shrugged, Wuthering Heights... and a few that were already Oprah's Book Club selections like East of Eden, The Good Earth, Ann Karenina...

But in the end, many of you told me to go for it and read:

Middlemarch

by George Eliot

Book Description: Bright, beautiful, and rebellious Dorothea has married the wrong man, and Lydgate--the ambitious new doctor in town--has married the wrong woman. Both of them long to make a positive difference in the world, but their lives do not proceed as expected. Along with the other inhabitants of Middlemarch, they must struggle to reconcile themselves to their fates and find their places in the world. (Vintage Classics)

Stayed tuned to my blog this summer for my thoughts on the book and let me know if you're going to read it along with me!

83 Comments
 

What Should I Read This Summer?

Posted on May 22, 2009 4:47 PM

I was talking to a colleague the other day who loves to read as much as I do. He said how much he's always been devoted to reading the classics but hasn't in a long time, so this summer he's taking on Dickens. And, I have another co-worker who decided tackle Tolstoy's War and Peace. So that got me thinking... I read a lot of contemporary fiction but every now and then I too, long for a classic novel. One with a great sweeping story about the human condition - it's food for my psyche and soul! So, I've decided to follow suit and this summer, along with all the other books I'm going to read, I'll also read a classic novel.

But the question is -- which one?

In an earlier blog ("Can I have too many books?") I wrote about how, much to my shame, I've never read Moby Dick. I could finally tackle that famous first line, "Call me Ishmael," and find out what happens next. But since that book will always be on my bookshelf one way or the other, I thought it would be more fun to ask you, our readers, to suggest a classic novel for me. So, I'm asking you to send me your suggestion and I will read the most popular book title and blog about it.

Now for selection purposes, I'd like to clarify that I'm looking for a novel that was written more than 50 years ago - the older the better! I would like to be transported to another time and place and I will leave it up to you how to interpret that.

So if you have a classic title you cherish or a book that made a huge difference in your life, tell me about it! Perhaps even some of you will want to read along with me. Let me know what you've read and loved and think I should read too. I will make my decision and announce it on this blog on Friday, June 5th, 2009.

469 Comments
 

Read the Book or Watch the Movie?

Posted on Apr 24, 2009 4:35 PM

One of the topics in a recent Oprah's Book Club newsletter was, "What Happens When a Book Makes It to the Big Screen?"

The Oprah.com newsletter highlights an interview with Bernhard Schlink, author of The Reader, a 1999 OBC selection and award winning movie starring Kate Winslet. When I read the book I was quite moved by Schlink's story of love and atonement. Even today, when I'm asked to recommend a past selection, The Reader is one of the titles I often suggest. I thought the novel was made into an excellent film (rent it if you haven't seen it), but this topic got me thinking about a question I'm often asked when a book is made into a film -- should I read the book or go see the film?

Although there's no substitute for hot buttered movie popcorn, I always answer -- read the book.

For me, reading is a journey and taking one with a truly well-crafted book is an extraordinary experience that is unique to the reading process. As the reader, you get to "cast" all the characters and do all the set design, but that is not to say that a film can't also deliver a memorable and sometimes even transformational experience.

But after seeing many a good book turned into mediocre a movie, I'm not so quick to want to see the pages I loved up on the big screen (remember the 1970s version of "The Great Gatsby?"). Sometimes I've been pleasantly surprised when the movie is even better than the book, which is how I feel about director David Lean's adaptation of Doctor Zhivago. It's a movie I will sit down and watch to the end no matter what time it's on -- I have to see that final scene on the cable car althought I know it will break my heart. And every time I see the movie, I always marvel at how a book I found to be rather dry was turned into such a passionate film.

Now you tell me, what do you like to do first -- read the book or see the movie? What are your favorite books that were made into movies you liked... or thought missed the mark?

AND -- If you haven't seen our weekly book club newsletter, you can sign up for it clicking on the link below... it's free!

https://www.oprah.com/mbr/mbr_edit_subscriptions.jsp

82 Comments
 

Can you have too many books?

Posted on Apr 3, 2009 3:49 PM

As part of my spring cleaning this year, I've decided to tackle my bookshelves. When I first put up my shelves my books only filled half the space, now every shelf is filled. And since they're so full, I've taken to piling any additional books all over my house - on the nightstand, the desk, some unused chairs, the cocktail table... you get the idea. But in my defense, I do so love living with books! I like revisiting the ones I've read and reordering the ones I'm going to read next. Yet I have to face facts, I didn't think this could happen but I believe I have too many books.

But which ones should I "pass on?" I plan to donate my books to a worthy cause, but how do I decide? Do I give up my paperback version of As I Lay Dying that has my high school doodles of fish in the margins? Should I finally give away my last copy of Palace Walk by Naguib Mahfouz, a classic title I often recommend to friends and family? Or do I part with my copy of Moby Dick, which I'm embarrassed to say I've never read but optimistically plan to every summer? Do I keep the hardcovers and release the paperbacks? Or, maybe I should try to keep them all because that's what "building" a personal library is about.

I think much like the journey you take when you read a story, the book itself is on a journey of its own when it comes into a reader's hands. And perhaps, the journey isn't over just because it's landed in mine. So I've decided I need to release my books back into the world so they can continue to entertain and engage new readers into the next millennium. After all, isn't that all we really have in the end to pass on? A story, a tale, a fable, a lesson that contains all the wisdom and folly we have learned from our too brief lives.

So tell me, what do your bookshelves look like?

68 Comments
 
1 2 | Next