In case you missed it - Oprah tweeted this week with some BIG book club news:
"Hey all you Book Clubbers. Tune in Friday, September 18th to find out what my new book club pick is-never made a selection like ‘this'."
We're all very excited around here. And, we're happy to see that so many people all over the web are trying to guess the title - it's exciting to see how much our readers love a mystery! But our lips are sealed so stay tuned...
Now for my thoughts on Middlemarch:
BOOK ONE: Miss Brooks
It takes me only a few pages to fall in love with the main character, Dorothea Brooks. Maybe I do because she reminds me of myself in some way - not the exceptional beauty part - but her pursuit of ideas that were not considered appropriate feminine interest. As the daughter of a scientist and mathematic, my father always encouraged me to pursue fields that - even as late as the 1970s - were consider strictly male. As more and more girls dropped out of my high school math and science classes, I continued on, not understanding why they didn't feel the thrill of scientific thinking and logic as I did. But when two of the most popular girls in the school asked me to be in their study group for chemistry class - I jumped at the chance to find some kind of feminine bond and social status. And when they decided it wasn't worth the effort to study for the final exam, I decided it wasn't either. I received a score I knew my efforts deserved but wounded my ego. In the end, that was the emotional catalyst* I needed to learn that all-important "passage of youth into maturity" lesson of being your own person in the face of social convention.
Okay, so I found a way to make the book all about me. Satisfied, I move on to part 2. But not before I also fall in love with Fred, the bon vivant brother of Rosamond whose rakish charm I feel will come to no good. I have to root for him anyway - perhaps the love of a grounded good woman like Mary Garth will bring out the best of him....
*Per Webster's and my high school science curriculum:
CATALYST: 1) a substance that enables a chemical reaction to proceed at a usually faster rate or under different conditions (as at a lower temperature) than otherwise possible. 2) an agent that provokes or speeds significant change or action.
BOOK 2: Old and Young
I'm all excited to meet Lydgate and read about the medical controversies of the day (there's a line about a legal reform regarding doctors and druggists which reminds me of a familiar debate about the relationship of pharmaceutical companies and doctors). When I get to the part about Lydgate's dangerous attraction to an actress who's accused of murdering her husband on-stage, I cannot put the book down! But that feeling passes as I read every footnotes (which I like having) in my edition (Bantam Classic) -- and slowing make my way to the end of this section.
I do remember reading somewhere that Eliot was criticized in her day about her inclusion of scientific subject matter. And as I'm reading I keep trying to wrap my brain around the fact that such a brilliant woman of the Victoria Era, with all that goes with being a women of that time, had the fortitude and perseverance to go against such overwhelming cultural convention to write her OWN story, not the one she was expected to tell. I guess learning to be your own person - or "standing in your truth" as Oprah often says on the show - is a lesson that transcends Victorian conventions and high school science labs and speaks to the universality of the human condition.
The Oprah Winfrey Show
Oprah's Best Life Series
Harpo Films
For One More Day
The Great Debaters
O, The Oprah Magazine
Subscribe Today
Oprah Radio
Oprah's Angel Network
Oprah's Book Club
I too liked Dorothea in the beginning of the book, and the fact that she was not like other women. However she started to bother me because sometimes she seemed to have contradictory views on issues just for the sake of having a different opinion; she seemed to make up her point of view on the spot, without having ever thought about it before. Particularly when she was with people she disliked. I only read ten chapters though, because the book was hard for me to get into and I had other books to read (just like Jill I have more books I want to read at a given time than is possible). I'm hoping the return to discussing the book might entice me to try continuing.
Can't wait to find out what Oprah's pick is. I don't have any guesses to venture, but I really want to know what type of selection it is, sounds exciting.